England Mountain Running Teams

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alphandomega

Is this a question? In which case this paragraph should have stopped with the ?

Or is it an opinion? As in whatever Pippa's wishes and the selectors' decision I know better?

Or is it a demonstration that you are illiterate as in "running" for "runner"?

Or that your PC has diarrhoea when it sees a ? or !, one usually being sufficient?

As to your final question- "No!"

---

He's only giving out an opinion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FellJunior

This is a matter for Pippa alone to discuss in private with the selectors, assuming she is unhappy at not being selected. End of.

---

Agreed.

As the vulgar phrase has it "everyone has an opinion" and they rarely coincide but only, repeat only, the Selectors have knowledge of the courses, the athletes' aspirations, the performance data, etc and the responsibility to make an informed selection and live with their decisions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alphandomega

Agreed.

As the vulgar phrase has it "everyone has an opinion" and they rarely coincide but only, repeat only, the Selectors have knowledge of the courses, the athletes' aspirations, the performance data, etc and the responsibility to make an informed selection and live with their decisions.

---

What about God? Does he not have this knowledge?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FellRunner1

He's only giving out an opinion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

---

Thanks for that .... thats the point of these forums surely?.

I thought it might make for an interesting debate as Pippa's fellow runners in Keswick are surprised that she has been left out of the team.

Still, we will be there mashalling etc as we did for the Trials.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Al Fowler

Im and out and out fellsman.:D

---

i'm just the resident clown :cool:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurboTom

Not fell race though are they, mountain races slight difference. More suited to road runners.
Honestly look at the list and i can only find 3 out an out fell runners. Jebby, Bailey and Swinbo. Maybe Andi and Katie Ingram fit into that as well. the rest are top quality road runners

---

I understand the difference but the 'up and down' race is more of a fell race. Local knowledge of the route would be very useful. The climbs are steep and the decent if wet, slippy.

As for the men, most of the out and out fell runners didn't bother turning up for the Trials.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FellMonster

What about God? Does he not have this knowledge?

---

A Revelation! Yes and that is why she is a Selector.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by keswickoldman

I understand the difference but the 'up and down' race is more of a fell race. Local knowledge of the route would be very useful. The climbs are steep and the decent if wet, slippy.

As for the men, most of the out and out fell runners didn't bother turning up for the Trials.

---

Rob Hope present
Danny Hope present
Simon Bailey presesnt
Ian Holmes present
Ricky Lightfoot present
Morgan Donnelly present.....
Lloyd Taggart present

I'm afraid by the time your Pipps hit the summit, not even an airplane would catch the front runners.....local knowledge is a poor substitute for speed over a lapped course on runnable terrain

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alphandomega

A Revelation! Yes and that is why she is a Selector.

---

Everybody knows God has a willy

On the right of forumites to question the selection policy, I think we have every right.
The authorities are the custodians of the sport on our behalf.

As a small time custodian in some way, I much prefer to have input and feedback (from my club members and race attendees) rather than nothing.
If the selectors were to get uppity about criticism, I am sure that they would not put themselves up there to be shot at.

Looking at the selection - and this is merely my opinion - I would say that had Pippa Jackson ran in the trial, she would have had a good chance of making the top four - but then again she might not have - I think the first 2 are clearly ahead of the rest at the moment and I would add Sarah Tunstall to that.
Probably the selectors could not pick too many wild cards or the trial would be discredited.
So Pippa was perhaps in the mix with Mary and Olivia, with the 2 trial attendees getting the nod.