I tried your first route choice a couple of weeks ago. I definitely seems the most direct and has least loss of height, but I still hope to find a more elegant route, as my little legs struggled to get over the conduit to the path on the other side.
Printable View
I think the other route is very similar (with slightly more climb), so I think it just comes down to which way it's easier to cross the stream - on the main path or over the conduit. I suspect the runnability on both routes will be similar.
Navigationally, I like crossing at the conduit, because it's easier to go up and over to the conduit before climbing straight to the pancake stone. If I remember rightly, crossing at the stream gives you a couple of paths to choose from and in the mist, it could be tricky to find the stone.
I did this last year, pretty sure there were some dogs along for the ride.
If anyone fancies a recce of most of the Rombalds Stride Route on sun, PM me - we'll be doing about 17miles in approx 2.5-3hrs (we'll be missing out the section from 12 apostles to Rocky Valley and instead will be dropping straight down the moor, but otherwise doing the whole route)
Think I saw you all and said hi. Hope you had a good run.
I was doing the opposite to you (climbing up from Burley Woodhead to the 12 Apostles and then doing the route back to Burley Woodhead. It was muddy out there but has been worse, and the flags beyond the trig point make it easier. I'm still not convinced by the climb over the stone cut between Rocky Valley and the Pancake Stone, but have still not found a better alternative. I did try the south side of the wall after Whestone Gate for the first time, and in wet weather it seems much faster the the 'proper' route on the north side.
Saw quite a few out today - hopefully we said hi back! I think we all had a good run. A few dropped out at Ilkley and got the train back (wimps!) - ended up running the last few bits over the fields and up the Chevin with a guy from Skyrac.
I tried the opposite to you today - dropped down to the stream from the end of the rocky valley and was then going to cut up to the Pancake Stone, but was running with my clubmate who wanted to stick to the letter of the written instructions. At least by dropping down to the rocks, we persuaded her that it was far better to stay higher and cut the corner - that climb back up to the ridge is awful.
Anyway back to my point. I don't think that the stream crossing on the main path is any quicker than crossing at the stone lined conduit higher up (it might be marginally easier if you aren't confident about jumping over the conduit), and I think it's more tricky from a navigational point of view to find the right path back up to the pancake stone. Cutting over to the right at the end of rocky valley and then down to the conduit is far easier - especially if visibility is low, since you've got a couple of catch points to guide you - 2 main paths, then the stream, then you're climbing straight back up and stay on the path to reach the pancake stone.
Anyone know what the entry limit is on this (had a search on LDWA and FRA and can't find it). I got my entry back (no. 483 I think??) but my brother who I'm meant to be running it with hasn't. Could it be a 500 limit?
All it says is "limited entry with strictly no entries on the day". It does now say FULL however.