Originally Posted by
Twister
You could be right, I'm doing everything in the X-talons and even brief sections of road to link up trails/footpaths to where I live and the hills. My terrain could be described as mixed. :) I have a number of routes which are on tracks and rocky paths like you. I think I may be pushing the Talons to their limits, the stickiness has gone and I can feel the studs a bit on the hard pack stuff. Let me know if you decide to go for the 285's I'd be interested to see what you think.
I am not really suffering from wearing the talons for everything, (I'm doing less and less in the Vibrams as I keep getting stone bruising). In fact I think that it's best to have less shoes. If you have a number of different shoes, for example a road shoe, trail shoe and a fell shoe, then your feet are going to be in slightly different positions when you run in each of these different shoes. I think that this maybe the cause of your knee pain. I'd imagine (although I'm not familiar with the model) that the Pearls could have a reasonable heel in them, if you were running a couple of times a week in these and then taking the Talons out for a long run on the weekend then the cause of the pain could be due to the change - It's a possibility anyway.
Try and go a few weeks in only one pair of shoes, and try and make your everyday shoes something really flat, like converse for example. Consider replacing road shoes with Vibrams or a flat.