I disagree. I think Carrol could be a top player.
Only could.
United signed rooney for 25 million, he had already scored many goals at international level and played almost twice as many games in the premiership. There was little risk.
I rate Carrol, big, good on the floor, fit, but, 35 million for unproven talent, Ronaldo was 80 million for guarenteed 25-40 goals a season plus many assists. To be honest that's now looking a steal.
I think Chelsea also got a very good price for Torres. Class player but definate blot on his reputation that he hasn't shown up for months. Despite wanting to leave Ronaldo's performances remained top draw for us, despite what people said. He produced.