Some very sanctimonious posts on here!

The AAC decision has brought the debate to the fore - which can only be a good thing. Yes there are some right plums on FB, but we'd be naive to think they weren't already running in races and get to the end more by chance than by use of pue "fell-craft". I posted this:

Wow - if nothing else this has definitely stirred up the debate! Even though I don't agree with all of the rules on the list, I think Ambleside are at least taking a stance and raising awareness and the fell running community needs to consider the implications.

Where do you draw the line on use of technology though? After all, even a paper map and a compass rely on "technology" or we'd all need to read moss or the stars to get round! Most maps are now produced using GPS information.. Compasses are not infallible.

Personally, I think using a GPS device to tell you where to run is unethical, but using one to relocate yourself on a map before you unknowingly drift into hypothermia is sensible (and that doesn't necessarily mean you have managed to make a rational decision that it is an emergency situation yet!).

GPS watches are so widely available now that the option is there for anyone to use them if they think it gives an advantage - just like a sticky rubber stud, or a 100g waterproof. Proper recceing will always still be quicker, as is reading the ground and knowing where your strengths are, so it's not a major advantage. Rather than try to fight the technology, I think it should be embraced with sensible rules to try and manage it fairly and ethically.

Bob Graham trained barefoot and ran his round in PJs and plimsolls - should we all abandon any sort of technological advance made since then and be doing the same? Perhaps knowing which side of a boulder the moss is growing on instead of a compass or a 1920s 1 inch to 1 mile map instead of an accurate GPS based modern OS?

Yes, we need rules and ethics that protect and reinforce what the spirit of fell-running is about, but not hypocrisy, luddism and sneering at those who don't yet know better.