Originally Posted by
Twister
Strongly disagree with your post. Where is the evidence - scientific peer reviewed, that states that your foot arch can't re-develop after the age of 12? Where did you get this little factoid from anyway? I don't think you can make statements like this without backing them up with some very good studies other than the anecdotal "if you don't believe me got to kenya"
It beggars belief that people who have experienced strength gains in their legs, through a sport such as fell running, would not be open to the thought that maybe, just maybe the foot can be strengthened as well.
Why do we need to generate spring from our foot arch? I thought that the arch was part of the cushioning system, its the achillies tendon where you want your spring, surely. Of course most people are used to day to day foot wear with a higher heel to toe, and running shoes that are the same and will have a shortened and ineffective achilles as a result.
Why do you think that the foot arch can't become more flexible with rehab exercise such as barefoot running? Have you tried it for yourself?
From a personal perspective I will never go back to a running shoe that isn't flat, or close to flat (zero differential from forefoot to heel) I've got 2 years of experience running minimalist (and barefoot at times) over rough trails, fells and mountains, with an ultra race under my belt using minimalist shoes. That's 2 years of injury free running, something that I haven't experienced since I started running competitively.
I feel that the minimalist shoe industry is not a rip off - it is a result of the many peer review studies in to barefoot biomechanics, the vast majority of minimal runners require a shoe that gives them just the right amount of protection and traction for the various terrains that they run on, the development of minimal shoes costs money, and its a niche market at the moment so they will be expensive. Interestingly, most minimal shoes seem to last a lot longer than normal shoes; I'm still on my first pair of vibrams, used for at least 5 miles each week, on forest track trail and malvern granite, and they're still looking good after almost 2 years.