Quote Originally Posted by christopher leigh View Post
Saz I've taken the above points into consideration for this question:

Who will run faster over the marathon distance.An athlete with an oxygen uptake of 6litres a min and a debt capacity of 10litres or the same athlete with an oxygen uptake of 4litres a min and a debt capacity of 15litres?
I expect we know what your question means, even if you don't because they wouldn't be the "same athlete" would they?

What you mean is "same in every other respect" but that would make your argument circular - which I think was obvious some time ago.