It’s a hard comparison to make to be honest – fell races tend to attract people who run in the hills all the time whilst road marathons tend to attract road runners, less keen on running in the hills. Hilly road marathons fall into the middle ground and certainly do put off the good runners that are chasing personal bests. There again I’m sure some fell runners are suddenly much more interested in having a bash. If ever I do run a marathon I’d go for Snowdon or Kielder or Windermere I’m sure.
Although I’ve never ever done a road marathon I have done the Langdale half marathon (in 1:41) which is a fantastically hilly course – the marathon run at the same time as the half is just two laps of the same route and I think the marathon winner the year did it ran a time of something like 3:10 !!!.
What I do know though is that fell races rarely attract fun runners and I always struggle when reviewing the starting line up to identify other runners that don’t look as fit as butchers dogs. In the few road races that I’ve run I’ve maybe managed to finish in the top 15% of the field whilst I’ve often struggled to be in the top 50% of fell races
